'The Norfolk Broads Phenomenon'

is available on Amazon in ebook format.

Click here to find out more on Amazon.

Navigating the Murky Waters of Electric Boats: A Sustainable Future?

Vlog series on Youtube
Post Reply
User avatar
Miles
Site Admin
Posts: 332
Joined: Wed Apr 26, 2023 9:03 am

Navigating the Murky Waters of Electric Boats: A Sustainable Future?

Post by Miles »



Navigating the Murky Waters of Electric Boats: A Sustainable Future?

In the ever-evolving landscape of transportation, whispers of the imminent demise of traditional combustion engines echo loudly. The prevailing narrative suggests that the familiar petrol and diesel engines gracing our roads may face obsolescence within the next decade. As of March 2021, Great Britain boasted 38.6 million licensed vehicles, sparking a contemplation of what a future dominated by electric vehicles might look like.

The Not-So-Green Reality of Electric Cars

The allure of electric cars hinges on their environmental friendliness. However, a critical examination of the statistics reveals a less-than-green reality. If all the licensed vehicles in Britain were electric, envision a nightly ritual where 38 million cars plug in simultaneously. The strain on the power grid becomes apparent, challenging the perceived eco-friendliness of electric cars.

Renewable energy sources like solar and wind power are often championed as the solution to this environmental conundrum. Yet, the production of solar farms and wind turbines involves substantial environmental costs. The materials required, while deemed renewable, may not always align with the true essence of green energy, posing a potential fallacy.

Electric Cars: A Resource-Intensive Dilemma

Delving deeper into the discussion, the sustainability of electric cars comes under scrutiny. The materials necessary for the production of massive modern wind turbines, in contrast to the simpler structures of old wind pumps, reveals an imbalance. The future of electric cars, considering the ethical and environmental implications of material sourcing, appears non-sustainable in the modern context.

An electric car, touted as a green alternative, ironically draws over seven kilowatts of electricity for a nightly recharge. This energy demand is equivalent to running seven kettles simultaneously, challenging the eco-friendly image of electric cars during the charging process.

Hydrogen: The Unpromoted Solution

While electric cars dominate the discourse, the true renewable power for vehicles lies in hydrogen. Governments recognize this potential, yet hydrogen power remains vastly under promoted. Finding hydrogen top-up points is as rare as hens' teeth in most countries, emphasising the lack of support for this cleaner alternative.

Impact on Boating Industry

The ripples of change extend to the boating industry, particularly evident on England's Norfolk Broads. Pleasure boats, often powered by ageing diesel engines, face scrutiny for their emissions. As traditional combustion engines phase out, the boat industry feels the pinch of increased fees and regulations driven by climate change concerns.

Electric Boats: A Challenging Transition

Contemplating the shift to electric boats unveils a myriad of challenges. Converting pleasure boats into electrically powered vessels presents financial hurdles, with infrastructure for charging and the availability of electric motors posing significant barriers. The cost of converting a sailboat to an electric motor ranges from several thousand to a substantial 25,000 pounds, making it a lofty investment for most boat owners.

The Future: Sails or Hydrogen?

As the push for greener waterways intensifies, options for electric boat conversion narrow. Returning to sails or embracing hydrogen-powered boat engines emerge as realistic alternatives. However, the feasibility of either option remains uncertain, leaving the future of electric boats on waterways like the Norfolk Broads hanging in the balance.

In conclusion, the journey towards sustainable watercraft faces turbulent waters. The choices ahead—sails or hydrogen—remain uncharted territories, and the likelihood of a definitive resolution appears elusive. As we navigate the uncertain seas of eco-friendly boating, the future remains both intriguing and uncertain.
Webmaster of the Norfolk Broads Forum
Post Reply