'The Norfolk Broads Phenomenon'

is available on Amazon in ebook format.

Click here to find out more on Amazon.

Boat Windows : Acrylic vs. Polycarbonate

Articles and videos about boat restoration and maintenance.
Post Reply
User avatar
Miles
Site Admin
Posts: 332
Joined: Wed Apr 26, 2023 9:03 am

Boat Windows : Acrylic vs. Polycarbonate

Post by Miles »



Acrylic vs. Polycarbonate: Choosing the Right Material for Your Boat Windows

In the realm of boat maintenance, the quest for knowledge is perpetual. Whether you're delving into the intricacies of mechanical systems, electrical components, woodwork, or fibreglass, the learning curve is a constant ascent. Today, our focus is on a perplexing choice many boat enthusiasts encounter: acrylic or polycarbonate for windows. Join me as we explore 17 key distinctions between these materials, unravelling the mysteries to help you make an informed decision for your vessel.

The Basics: Acrylic and Polycarbonate

Both acrylic and polycarbonate boast impressive impact resistance, positioning themselves as formidable alternatives to traditional glass. Notably, they each weigh half as much as glass, making them lightweight choices for boat applications. Let's dive into the specifics of these materials.

Acrylic:

- **Aliases:** Also known as Lucite, Optics, or Plexiglas.
- **Strength:** Acrylic offers 10 to 24 times the impact resistance of glass.
- **Appearance:** Generally shinier and slightly more transparent than polycarbonate.
- **Colour Options:** Available in an extensive array of colours.
- **Scratch Resistance:** Prone to scratches, but easier to repair than polycarbonate.
- **Cost:** Typically more affordable than polycarbonate.
- **Workability:** Easier to cut and polish to a smooth finish.

Polycarbonate:

- **Aliases:** Known as Lexan or Makrolon.
- **Strength:** Boasts over 30 times the impact resistance of glass.
- **Appearance:** Less shiny than acrylic but stronger.
- **Colour Options:** Limited colour choices compared to acrylic.
- **Scratch Resistance:** Susceptible to scratches, with more challenging repairs.
- **Cost:** Often more expensive than acrylic.
- **Workability:** Better for drilling and resistant to breaking, especially near edges.

Choosing the Right Material: Considerations

1. Transparency and Clarity

Acrylic tends to be clearer and more transparent than polycarbonate. If visual clarity is a top priority, acrylic might be your preferred choice.

2. Color Options

Acrylic outshines polycarbonate when it comes to colour variety. If aesthetics play a significant role in your decision, the vibrant palette of acrylic might be appealing.

3. UV Resistance

Both materials are susceptible to UV damage, but polycarbonate has a slight edge in resisting yellowing over prolonged exposure to sunlight.

4. Cost

While acrylic is generally more budget-friendly, polycarbonate's superior strength justifies its higher price point in many cases.

5. Workability

If you need to cut and polish with ease, acrylic is the winner. However, for drilling and structural integrity, especially near edges, polycarbonate takes the lead.

6. Heat Resistance

Polycarbonate surpasses acrylic in handling heat, making it a better choice for areas prone to high temperatures.

7. Chemical Resistance

In environments where exposure to acids and chemicals is a concern, polycarbonate emerges as the more resilient option.

8. Flexibility

Polycarbonate offers both rigid and flexible grades, providing versatility for various applications. Acrylic, on the other hand, is known for its rigidity.

9. Cold Forming

If cold forming and bending without heat are essential, polycarbonate is the go-to choice.

10. Environmental Impact

Both acrylic and polycarbonate proudly share the eco-friendly badge, of being 100% recyclable.

In the acrylic vs. polycarbonate showdown for boat windows, the choice boils down to your specific needs. If clarity, colour variety, and cost are paramount, acrylic is a strong contender. On the other hand, if unparalleled strength, heat resistance, and chemical resilience are non-negotiable, polycarbonate takes the lead. Whichever you choose, rest assured that both materials are salt-resistant, making them excellent options for coastal areas. So, as you contemplate upgrading your boat's windows, armed with this knowledge, you're ready to set sail into a clear and sturdy future.
Webmaster of the Norfolk Broads Forum
Post Reply